The rape and strangulation death of Brenda Lee Ritter, 18, of North Strabane Township on May 19, 1977 is a case that still haunts police.
Her death occurred as the fourth in a series of slayings of young women in Washington County. The murders of Deborah Capiola, Mary Irene Gency and Susan Rush left county residents on edge. The death of Barbara Lewis in Penn Hills within the same time frame left investigators wondering if her strangulation death was at the hands of the same killer.
According to a Sept. 28, 2003 story in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Brenda left her boyfriend's home in Chartiers Township about 10:10 p.m. May 18, 1977 during a raging thunderstorm. Her boyfriend, Larry Bonazza, and his mother made sure the doors of Brenda's Ford Pinto were locked because of the slayings—then watched her drive away into the storm.
The slender blonde worked as a secretary for Kennedy and Carter, a Washington construction firm. Brenda's abandoned car was found in neighboring South Strabane the next morning.
Before a massive search got under way that afternoon, searchers in a state police helicopter spotted Brenda's nearly nude remains on a hillside off rural Roupe Road, about three-quarters of a mile from her car. Her clothes were also found within about 50 feet of her body. South Strabane and North Strabane police received the help of 25 Pennsylvania state troopers in their investigation.
As a result of those efforts, investigators determined that Brenda was raped, and then strangled using a tourniquet-type device made from her panties and a stick. Farrell Jackson, then Washington County coroner, said tests placed the time of death at between 11:30 p.m. and midnight.
Some forensic evidence—including hair and fingerprints—was found in the car.
At one point, a broken bracelet with the name "Jack" engraved on it, which was found in the vicinity of the murder, was considered as potential evidence. Tests run on Brenda to see if a drug was used in her abduction came back negative.
Donald Zofchak, South Stabane police chief at the time, said an investigation determined Brenda had not taken her normal route home from the Meadow Lands, where the Bonazzas lived. At the time, there was some thought among investigators that perhaps someone posing as a police officer could have gained access to Brenda's car without a fight. Her car appeared to have no damage.
Jackson shared a profile of the killer shortly after Brenda's murder, describing him as "between 20 and 30, not unattractive but average in appearance; not too intelligent but smart enough to know his victim's routes and follow them ... and began his sex life rather late and gets violent after the sex act." According to that profile, that man would likely be between 55 and 65 years old today.
There was some hope of solving Brenda's murder in 1983 when Henry Lee Lucas, a serial killer in Texas, admitted to killing women in 16 states. But he was never charged in Brenda's death—nor in any of the murders of area young women during that era.