UPDATED: ID Now Required to Vote

The governor signed the bill into law Thursday.

The state House on Wednesday approved legislation that requires voters to present identification at the polls.

The legislation, House Bill 934, requires each voter to present proof of identification at every election.

Gov. Tom Corbett signed the bill into law Thursday.

“I am signing this bill because it protects a sacred principle, one shared by every citizen of this nation. That principle is: one person, one vote,’’ Corbett said. “It sets a simple and clear standard to protect the integrity of our elections.’’

The law goes into effect immediately, but the photo ID will not be required for the primary election next month. However, voters will be reminded at that time that a photo ID will be required for November’s general election.

Proponents of the bill, such as House Majority Leader Mike Turzai, R-Allegheny County, lauded the bill, saying it will “strengthen voter identification and enfranchise all voters.”

The state will provide non-driver identification cards for those who need it, free of charge.

According to Turzai, a uniform voter identification requirement “assures all voters will be treated equally and fairly and will prevent some voters from being singled out for identification while other voters are allowed to vote without identifying themselves.”

But state , D-Cecil Township, disagreed.

White voted no on the bill—saying that several flaws with the legislation jumped out during floor debate.

Take the issue of disabled veterans and their identification, for example.

He said because of technical requirements in the legislation regarding acceptable forms of identification, the type now issued to disabled veterans “would not qualify under the bill.”

“It could actually have the unintended consequence of disenfranchising voters who fought and shed blood for our country,” he said.

White added: "Voting is a fundamental, constitutional right, and if we're going to do anything that infringes on that right, we need to make sure no one will be disenfrachised. This bill fails at that spectacularly."

And he said that while proponents of the bill have said the legislation "isn't about the 2012 election, the fact the majority rammed it through after acknowledging that there were flaws certainly makes you wonder whether this was more about politics than policy."

State said he voted no on the bill—as did all House Democrats and three Republicans—for many reasons, one of them financial.

“I voted no because it’s going to cost $11 million to implement,” Neuman, D-North Strabane, said, adding that there isn’t even any evidence that voter fraud is happening at the polls.

As for the "free" identification cards?

"It's not free—it's taxpayer dollars," he said.

Neuman added that, if there is fraud in the system, it would be in the registration process, not the voting process, and he said that’s what legislation should address.

“It would stop the fraud, if there is any fraud, where it begins,” Neuman said.

He also said it puts poll workers in a position to not only ask for identification, but also spot fake IDs—something they aren't trained to do.

"This bill sounds so innocent, but it's not," he said, adding that similar laws in other states have been challenged and overturned in the courts.

The state Senate passed the bill last week, with state , D-Canonsburg, voting no.

cecil resident March 19, 2012 at 02:07 PM
The United States’ voter registration system is in chaos — about 24 million registrations are no longer valid and nearly 2 million dead people are still on voter rolls, according to a new report . Along with the one of every eight voter registrations that is not valid or has significant inaccuracies, there are 2.75 million people currently registered to vote in more than one state, the PEW CENTER on the States study found, so much for your registration review system. This is not a Democratic or Republican study this is just a way for voter fraud to run wild. If a person doesn't have their proof they can file a provisional ballot and they have time to produce the proof they need to make their vote count. This votor ID is a start to stop any chance of fraud no law is perfect just because we never had a law like this on the books for years doesn't mean it is not time to start. Every legal American voter should be glad that their candidate be a Republican or Democrat is getting their votes fair and square
Roger March 19, 2012 at 09:58 PM
Suzanne, I think the heart of your question about "why now" is answered in a previous comment. One word: ACORN.
Alexander M. Cianfracco March 19, 2012 at 11:20 PM
Roger, this bill would NOT stop fraudulent voter registration, so even if your precious ACORN theory was correct, this bill does NOTHING to stop it. Why bother arguing? You're all so damn howl at the wind convinced that you're right because those pesky Democrats keep trying to steal your precious freedom, even though you're too stupid to see it is actually being taken by the corporate whores and evangelical wackos running the GOP.
Roger March 19, 2012 at 11:48 PM
Alexander, ... I guess when arguments fail, name-calling is the next resort. This is not an R or D issue. Why do people wish to make it one?
Amanda Gillooly March 20, 2012 at 01:46 AM
Let's keep is civil please, folks. Thanks!!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »